Personal Injury Settlement Mills
How personal injury settlement mills operate
When people think about hiring a personal injury lawyer they expect, quite naturally, that their personal injury attorney will assess their claim, determine a unique course of action that will best represent their claim and try to obtain fair value for the client’s injury whether that is through settlement or litigation. However, Standford law professor Nora Engstrom conducted an extensive study of the personal injury law firms she dubbed “settlement mills” and how they do business. Professor Engstrom’s study found that these firms do not represent clients individually. Instead, these personal injury firms use the volume of clients to push settlements with the insurance companies. If her analysis had merely reached the conclusion that these firms are able to swiftly result in settlements then we would probably say that’s a good thing. However, Professor Engstrom’s analysis did not end there. She found that the firms push settlement based on value that will reach settlement rather than reach fair value for their clients.
Her analysis found that most cases were resolved by a formula, rather than the particular strengths or weaknesses of the case, and that produces disappointing results. Cases most probable to result in large verdicts were settled at a deep discount. Most cases end up settling at a discount well below what jury verdicts suggest is fair value on the claims. In fact, her analysis suggests the stronger the case, the less value the client actually received. The only cases that tended to benefit from this churn-and-burn and lawsuit-by-numbers process were clients with small claims and a low probability of success at trial because both sides (the insurance company and the personal injury firm) benefit from settling all of their claims. It’s easier for them that way. However, to get a few small cases settled, a larger number of clients with strong cases give up a lot more than those clients with weak cases gain. It’s mostly just a win for the lawyers and the insurers.
What you should consider in a personal injury lawyer
If you have a personal injury claim you should consider what you are looking to accomplish when hiring a lawyer. If you just want your medical bills paid and to get everything done quickly then a personal injury law firm that may be dubbed a “settlement mill” might be a good option. However, I find most people are looking for fair value on their claims, even if it means taking a little longer or putting up more of a fight. Your claims may be worth much more than a generic formula designed to grab a quick settlement may offer. If you are interested in speaking with a lawyer who will assess your claims based on their own merits, contact my office to schedule an appointment.
Photo courtesy of freedigitalphotos.net